Traditional Leaders in a Democracy: Resources, Respect and Resistance

Authors

Mbongiseni Buthelezi; Dineo Skosana; Beth Vale; Joel Netshitenzhe; Aninka Claassens; Peter Delius; William Ellis; Nkosi Phathekile Holomisa (Ah! Dilizintaba); Sonwabile Mnwana; Sindiso Mnisi Weeks; Tlhabane Mokhine ‘Dan’ Motaung; Fani Ncapayi; Nkosi Mwelo Nonkonyana (Zanemvula); Sithandiwe Yeni

Keywords:

traditional leaders, democracy, MISTRA

Synopsis

Traditional Leaders in a Democracy: Resources, Respect and Resistance explores how chieftaincy is practised, experienced and contested in contemporary South Africa. It explores how those living under the authority of chiefs, in a modern democracy, negotiate or resist these politics in their respective areas. Post-1994, South Africa’s traditional leaders have fought for recognition, and positioned themselves as major players in our political landscape. Yet their role in a democracy is contested, with leaders often accused of abusing power, disregarding human rights, expropriating resources and promoting tribalism. Some argue that democracy and traditional leadership are irredeemably opposed and cannot co-exist. Meanwhile, shifts in the political economy of the former bantustans − the introduction of platinum mining in particular − have attracted new interests and conflicts to these areas, with chiefs often designated as custodians of community interests.

Chapters

  • Preface
    Joel Netshitenzhe
  • Acknowledgements
  • Contributors
  • One
    Collisions, collusions and coalescences
    Mbongiseni Buthelezi, Beth Vale
  • Section One
  • Two
    Mistaking form for substance
    Peter Delius
  • Three
    Traditional leadership and the African National Congress in South Africa
    Dineo Skosana
  • Four
    Mining magnates and traditional leaders
    Aninka Claassens
  • Section Two
    ‘Development’ and Distributive Struggles
  • Five
    Chiefs, land and distributive struggles on the platinum belt, South Africa
    Sonwabile Mnwana
  • Six
    Traditional leadership, violation of land rights and resistance from below in Makhasaneni village, KwaZulu-Natal
    Sithandiwe Yeni
  • Section Three
    Leadership and Legitimacy
  • Seven
    The violence of the harmony model
    Sindiso Mnisi Weeks
  • Eight
    Chieftaincy succession disputes among the AmaNdebele-a-Moletlane in Hammanskraal, 1962 to 1994
    Tlhabane Mokhine ‘Dan’ Motaung
  • Nine
    Emerging rural struggles against unelected traditional authorities and the role of the courts
    Fani Ncapayi
  • Ten
    Situational chiefs
    William Ellis
  • Section Four
    Opinions from Two Traditional Leaders
  • Eleven
    In defence of traditional leadership
    Nkosi Phathekile Holomisa (Ah! Dilizintaba)
  • Twelve
    A long walk for traditional leadership in South Africa
    Nkosi Mwelo Nonkonyana (Zanemvula)
  • Towards Conclusions
    Traditional leadership
    Dineo Skosana
  • Index
Traditional Leaders Cover

Downloads

Published

January 1, 2019

Categories